Flying fish and “a big bang” create Hartfield puzzler

Sonia Honaker

by Tom Chillemi – 

Sonia Honaker has seen a lot during 50 years at her riverfront home in the upper reaches of the Piankatank River.

Eagles and ospreys live here and fish these waters hunting in early morning and late afternoon until dusk. The numbers have improved for the ospreys but the eagles are not as plentiful. “I have witnessed up to six ospreys hunting at the same time . . . maybe they’re training the younger birds.”

Honaker said that in all her years on the river since 1967, there’s been some really unusual things — a snapping turtle as big as a tire, an airplane crash (no one was hurt), boat races, and even a black swan. But after all this, a “flying fish” tops the list of things that happened at her Piankatank Shores subdivision near Hartfield in Middlesex County.

There’s a saying by Ben Franklin that goes something like this, “Don’t believe anything you hear, and only half of what you see.” This could be one of those stories that’s hard to believe.

It was a regular Monday afternoon in early spring 2020, Brenton Honaker was watching TV at his Piankatank Shores home when all of a sudden he heard “a big bang” and then glass breaking. He looked outside, didn’t see anything, so he went out to investigate. “I walked towards the front of the house, nothing,” said Brenton. “I went to the side of the house and I saw what hit it.” There on the ground lay a large croaker, maybe four pounds. A minute earlier it had been a projectile speeding towards his window. The impact broke the glass and left a mess.

“I guess flying fish are the next thing to look out for,” he joked. “I will be replacing the window and mom will be eating the croaker.” It’s in the freezer.

So what happened? Fish don’t fly . . . but birds do. The fish probably slipped from the talons of an osprey or eagle, said Sonia Honaker, Brenton’s mother. The birds may have been fighting for the fish, a raider trying to steal dinner. 

It was a rare day — the kind that might only come along once in a long while. 

Rivah Visitor's Guide Staff
Rivah Visitor's Guide Staff
The Rivah Visitor’s Guide provides information about places to go and things to do throughout the Northern Neck and Middle Peninsula of Virginia’s Chesapeake Bay region, from the York River to the Potomac River.

Related Reading

‘World’s Flattest Marathon’: Quality experiences for all runners

Fewer than one percent of people in the world will ever complete a marathon in their lifetime. Runners dedicate months of...

Fall is festival time in the Northern Neck

What better way to kick off autumn than with family-friendly festivals. Although there are dozens of festivals, from those centered around our...

The Tavern Cafe: A simple retreat for a...

Stepping into Rice’s Hotel/Hughlett’s Tavern is stepping between then and now. The building, with some portions dating from the late 1700s,...
MPMCPiers
Easterforshrff_300x250
DrKeeney
Malise2026

The Fishing Line

Salty tales and fish scales – the bay buffet 

If forty years of steering folks across the Chesapeake Bay and its twisting tributaries has taught me anything, it’s that Mother Nature has a...

It Happened Here

It Happened Here: Dimes, Quarters, Watermelons & Newspapers

The Simmons brothers, Wroten and Stewart of Lancaster County, owned the Chesapeake Bay buyboat “Seven Brothers.” They are the same Simmons who lived on...

The Tavern Cafe: A simple retreat for a satisfying bite to eat

Stepping into Rice’s Hotel/Hughlett’s Tavern is stepping between then and now. The building, with some portions dating from the late 1700s, houses the Northern...
Kilmarnock
clear sky
53.7 ° F
57 °
49.7 °
84%
5.7mph
0%
Wed
66 °
Thu
67 °
Fri
58 °
Sat
60 °
Sun
59 °

Local Tides