
If a one-of-a-kind, handmade gift is on your shopping list this holiday season, then you have it made—Made in Mathews, that is.
The Middle Peninsula county will welcome visitors to shop and browse original, distinctive treasures and admire artists at work during its 2026 Made in Mathews Open Studio Tour, happening back-to-back weekends, Friday through Sunday, November 27-29, and Saturday and Sunday, December 5-6.
The drive-yourself, free tour offers an array of fine art, textiles, furniture, jewelry, glass, sculptures and home and body products, all handmade in Mathews County. Enjoy a leisurely drive through the picturesque backroads where you’ll meet artists making their crafts at their home studios.
“I love to go into their creative world and see their studios. It’s part of the magic,” said Jeannine Kersey Johnson, the new business manager at Mathews County Visitor & Information Center (MCVIC). The center, on Main Street in the former iconic Sibley’s General Store, is one of the 12 stops on the tour and “is a great spot to start [the tour]. We’re here to welcome people, help them figure out the town, where they want to go and answer questions,” added Johnson. “Also we’ll be all set up for the holiday here.”
As a bonus, the visitor center is chock full of Mathews County souvenirs and handmade gift items from over 100 Mathews-specific artisans.

After receiving a warm welcome there from the jubilant and bubbly Johnson, visitors can plot out their own tours, said Karen Pittman, who calls Johnson a wonderful addition to MCVIC and the “happiest person I know.”

Pittman, an oil painter and watercolorist, is the “lead” on this year’s tour and her studio in New Point is stop #10.
Pittman has been on the tour since 2020 and this year her studio is only open during the Thanksgiving weekend. There are four artisans whose studios and workshops are only on the tour for the Thanksgiving weekend, including Tamara Rollins with Moonstruck Soap, Susan Brodie Art, and P. Buckley Moss Galleries. Rollins is one of Johnson’s favorite artisans on the tour, as is Rosalie Brown of Bentwaters Farm in Susan. Brown offers hand-crafted woven and spun items with wool from on-site.
“Rosalie has her own sheep, so your visit is like you’re going to a farm,” said Johnson. “Which makes that stop so fun.”
Brown and Lynn Abrams at D’Lynn Glass Design Studio were two of the original artisans on the first tour 25 years ago. In fact, the tour was the brainchild of Abrams, Brown and a few others artisans in 2001, said Pittman. It “was conceived to promote and unify the efforts of artists in the area doing individual studio tours. They wanted to bring visibility to the amazing arts and artists in the county.”
Artists paid a fee to be part of the tour and help with promotional costs. Following the tour, they’d gather to discuss successes and strategies for next year.
“The current group of 12 still follows this model,” said Pittman.
Artists are juried-in, must have a home studio, have plenty of parking and plenty of inventory. “We try not to duplicate and have a varied group,” said Pittman, with not too many using the same medium.
Each studio usually has a give-away or drawing, according to Pittman.
It’s estimated that 700 to 1,000 folks attend the tour each year, said Pittman, who added it draws visitors from as far as Richmond, Williamsburg and Northern Virginia. “We’ve even had visitors from Europe and all over the U.S.,” she said. “They come to see what our wonderful county has to offer. This is a huge stimulus to the local economy with restaurants and B&Bs.”
To visit all 12 studios would probably be a day-long adventure, according to Johnson. But because it’s a self-guided tour, visitors can pick and choose which places to visit.
A Made in Mathews Open Studio Student Art Competition is now in its sixth year. Cash prizes are given to both middle and high school winners. “Last year we had over 90 entries,” said Pittman. “There’s also a gallery opening for parents, teachers and the community to help encourage the next generation of artists.”
Maps and additional tour stop information are available at the visitor center, at MadeInMathews.com or on the Made in Mathews Facebook page.
“We are proud to be in our 25th year and look to the future to promote the local arts to the next generations,” said Pittman.
Stops along the Made in Mathews Open Studio Tour

1. Arnie Gustafson Into Woods
240 Dogwood Lane, Cobbs Creek
Functional and decorative wood bowls made from local Virginia trees (Closed both Sundays of tour)
2. Mermaid Cove Productions
83 Gwynn Street, Gwynn
Photography, fine art prints and books
3. Mathews Visitor Center
239 Main Street, Mathews
Local handmade goods, tour information *A good place to start the tour
4. Bay School Community Arts Center
279 Main Street, Mathews
Over 80 local and regional artists (Short walk from visitor’s center)
5. Moonstruck Soap
1041 New Point Comfort Highway, Mathews
Hand-crafted soaps (November 27-29 only)
6. Susan Brodie Art
171 Aldebaran Road, Mathews
Paintings and ceramics (November 27-29 only)
7. P. Buckley Moss Galleries
74 Poplar Grove Lane, Mathews
Original paintings and artwork (November 27-29 only)
8. Artisans at Sloop Creek
53 Sloop Creek Road, Port Haywood
Sewn, quilted, crocheted and knitted creations along with jewelry and glass art on display by D’Lynn Glass
9. D’Lynn Glass Design Studio
53 Sloop Creek Road, Port Haywood
Jewelry and glass art. Demos in the studio
10. Karen Pittman Art
7882 New Point Comfort Highway, New Point
Coastal landscapes in oil, watercolor and acrylic (November 27-29 only)
11. Lisa Capen Quilts
287 Circle Drive, Port Haywood
Fabric and thread designs
12. Bentwaters Farm
1083 Circle Drive, Susan
Hand-crafted woven items and accessories and hand-carved Treenware
Creativity gets a boost from active visitor and arts centers
Although the Made in Mathews Open Studio Tour is celebrating a quarter century this year, the Mathews County Visitor and Information Center (MCVIC) and Bay School Community Arts Center joined the tour just six years ago in 2020.
Locals and frequent, longtime visitors to the small Middle Peninsula county will remember the former occupant of the now Mathews County Visitor and Information Center—Sibley’s General Store.
First opened as Sibley Brothers in 1898, Sibley’s was more than a general store, where residents could find everything from hardware to bait. It was a meeting place, where folks gathered around the wood stove to tell tales.
The store was sold by the Sibley family in 1989 and still functioned as a general store for many more years. It was leased by MCVIC in 2006 and a major renovation was recently completed.
Although it’s now filled with handcrafted items from over 100 Mathews-specific artists, new business manager Jeannine Kersey Johnson would love to see the center become a gathering place of sorts again.
“I’m so glad we can capture some of that simpler time here,” said Johnson, who added she’d love to have residents and visitors come in, sit with a cup of coffee and chat.
Just a few doors down Main Street from MCVIC is the Bay School Community Arts Center, where creation takes shape. Founded in 1997, Bay School is a community arts center which not only serves as a gallery where artists display and sell their work but it is a working studio. Artists teach over 100 classes each year in and out of the building.
MCVIC is open seven days a week, from 10 a.m.-4 p.m. Mondays through Saturdays and from noon-3 p.m. on Sundays.
The Bay School is open from 10 a.m.-4 p.m. Mondays through Wednesdays, 10 a.m.-5 p.m. on Thursdays and Fridays, and 10 a.m.-4 p.m. on Saturdays. It also hosts classes and special events on select nights and Sundays throughout the year. Visit bayschoolarts.org to find out more about special holiday-related events.









